For Agents & Brokers · Updated October 2026

American Real Estate Association (ARA) vs. NAR: Why Agents Want a Better Way

A record settlement, rising dues and now MLSs suing one of the country's largest brokerages. More agents and brokers are asking whether NAR still serves them, and whether ARA is the answer. Here's how the two compare, and why your MLS decision may matter more than either.

The Short Answer

NAR is the long-established trade association that owns the REALTOR® trademark and works through local and state boards, many of which also run the local MLS.

ARA is a newer national trade association, founded in 2024, positioned as an alternative to NAR.

Neither one is a real estate license, and neither is required to join MYStateMLS.

Why So Many Agents Are Rethinking NAR

The $418 Million Settlement

In 2024, NAR settled the commission lawsuits for $418 million. Since August 17, 2024, buyer-agent compensation offers no longer appear on the MLS, and buyers must sign written agreements before touring homes.

Stacked Dues

REALTOR® membership typically means paying local, state and national dues, and in many markets that's the price of getting MLS access.

Shrinking Membership

NAR membership has declined for several years in a row as agents question what they're getting for their dues.

What Is the American Real Estate Association?

ARA launched in 2024, co-founded by Mauricio Umansky, founder and CEO of The Agency, and Jason Haber, a Compass-affiliated agent. It has grown to about 30,000 members and has signed up major brokerages, including Douglas Elliman, The Agency, RE/MAX and R New York. Its first local chapter is in New York. In July 2026, Compass partnered with ARA and offered its agents complimentary memberships through 2027.

ARA isn't a REALTOR® association, so members can't use the REALTOR® designation unless they also belong to NAR. Many agents who join ARA keep their NAR membership.

ARA vs. NAR at a Glance

NARARA
Founded19082024
StructureNational, state and local boardsNational association with growing local chapters
REALTOR® designationYesNo
MLS accessOften bundled through board-owned MLSsNot an MLS; access is a separate decision
Replaces your license?NoNo

Now the MLSs Are Suing Compass

The latest fight shows how tangled this business has become. Compass, one of the largest brokerages in the country, wants to publicly market some listings without first sharing them through the MLS, and it has argued that MLS cooperation rules illegally restrict how agents and homeowners market property.

The MLSs are pushing back in court:

  • October 5, 2026: California Regional MLS (CRMLS) sued Compass. Compass then sued CRMLS.
  • October 21, 2026: Six more MLSs (ARMLS, BridgeMLS, Canopy MLS, Doorify MLS, Hive MLS and REcolorado) filed a federal lawsuit asking a court to declare their rules legal and to block Compass from suing them.
  • Earlier: Northwest MLS settled an antitrust lawsuit with Compass in September.

The MLSs say Compass wants the benefits of the cooperative while holding back listings. Compass says the rules hurt competition. And Compass is now ARA's biggest new partner.

Does Anyone Else See a Problem With This?

The associations, the brokerages and the MLSs are fighting each other. Agents and their sellers are caught in the middle.

Switching from one trade association to another doesn't fix that. There has to be a better way to do this business, and it starts with separating your MLS from the politics.

The Better Way: Separate Your MLS From Your Association

Whether you stay with NAR, join ARA, belong to both or neither, your MLS is what actually puts your listings in front of buyers. In many markets, MLS access is tied to board membership. It doesn't have to be.

How MYStateMLS Works

  • No board or association required. Not NAR, not ARA, not a local board.
  • Open to any licensee: salespersons, brokers, appraisers, auctioneers and mobile home dealers.
  • Statewide and nationwide reach. NYStateMLS is the statewide MLS for New York and part of MYStateMLS.
  • Syndication of Choice. You and your seller decide where the listing goes.

Google is now showing MLS listings in search

Through the Google/HouseCanary (ComeHome) listings program, participating MLSs' listings can appear directly in Google search results. MYStateMLS is one of the founding participants. If your MLS isn't part of it, your listings may be missing from results your competitors appear in.

Watch: What Google's MLS listings mean for agents (7 min) →

For more, read MLS Membership Versus Local Boards Explained and How to Get MLS Access in New York.

Questions to Ask Before You Join or Leave Any Association

  1. If I leave, do I lose MLS access, or can I get it another way?
  2. What will I pay in total dues each year, and what do I get for them?
  3. Do my clients or my brokerage care about the REALTOR® designation?
  4. Who controls where my listings are syndicated?
  5. Does my association's direction match the business I want to build?

Frequently Asked Questions

Is ARA a replacement for NAR?

It's an alternative trade association, not a direct replacement. ARA members can't use the REALTOR® designation, and many agents belong to both.

Do I need to be a REALTOR® to get MLS access?

Not with MYStateMLS. It has no board or association requirement. You only need an active license.

Can ARA members join MYStateMLS?

Yes. Any licensed agent or broker can join MYStateMLS, whether they belong to ARA, NAR, both or neither.

Is joining ARA or NAR the same as being licensed?

No. Your license comes from the state. Trade association membership is optional and separate.

There's a Better Way

MLS Access Without the Board Politics

MLS Membership

Join MYStateMLS

Statewide and nationwide reach, Syndication of Choice, and no board or association membership required.

Learn How to Join

Certification

National MLS Marketing Specialist™

Learn to turn nationwide exposure and Syndication of Choice into a marketing advantage with your sellers.

See the Certification

Thinking about leaving your board? Let's talk through your options.

Book 30 Minutes With John